What gets me is despite everything that has happened some people say the parties are the same. For them to believe that what the parties do has no effect on their life. They are most likely doing so well they can ignore a lot of things.
The onus is on the candidate to not support genocide. Not on tom for having a principled stance of not voting for someone who is supporting it.
I voted for Harris. But it didn’t feel great. It felt selfish. But I do vote lesser two evils, it would just be nice to vote for something more.
Harris’ policy ideas were business as usual and crap, she made no break from Bidens atrocious support of genocide, she was sounding like a neo con while campaigning with them. And Boxed out Walz the last month to hang with republicans. Was talk she was catering to the likes of Mark Cuban and other crap billionaires and was gonna push out the incredible Lina Khan. All these were choices by the candidate.
So, how could you tell someone, hey vote this way, yea mass murder will happen but it’ll be less mass murder.
And yea, I’m fucking pissed the election went to the rapist insurrectionist. I’m mad that Harris ran a shit campaign, I’m mad that 77 mil voted for the orange POS. Hell, I’m even a mad at Tom, but also have a hard time articulating that anger, because how the hell could I be, when he couldn’t vote for continuing a genocide.
It’s a tough thing to deal with. My kids less safe. My parents less safe. Having hard time affording shit, fascism is here and it’s sick.
So I could stay mad at a Tom, or I could place my anger at those who actually hold power, who actually could be more and choose not to. And I will push on them to be better . To push for health care, education, climate change policy so we actually have future, abolishment of ICE, and holding this corrupt regime accountable for the corruption, death, and destruction. Push those and hold those who have their hands on the levers of power to account.
Or we can keep wasting time yelling at those who couldn’t talk themselves into voting for genocide.
1) Democrats have to be better at winning over more voters and we should always push them to improve, because them losing to a party that had descended into nihilism is more than we can afford (this is no longer “losing to Dole’ after all)
2) As voters, we really have to make the best choice available even if we are unhappy with the alternatives. “Lesser of two evils” sounds bad but “letting the greater of two evils win” is obviously far worse.
Also, not voting never seems to cause the losing party to say “wow those people who didn’t vote for us had a point”. They just assume you were unmotivated and probably can’t be motivated. Showing up though—that does get noticed and pols do try to cater to their coalition. Be vocal with your criticism, help the better option win, and continue pressuring them after the election. Better yet, win over more converts, because pols read polls and they can do math.
I vote for Democrats, but I don't suffer under the delusion that they're going to do much more than slow down the slide into permanent Republican rule.
Between party leadership being quisling bastards and a huge chunk of the main body of the party listening to Republican outfits like third way and whatever consultants got hired this week I don't think this country is going anywhere but down.
Whether a country that used agent orange, white phosphorus, and dropped two nuclear bombs on civilian populations deserves to continue is a moral question in and of itself, and I'm on team "no, fuck that", but that's a different discussion entirely.
If Harris had won, we wouldn't have started a war with Iran. We wouldn't be arresting people at their immigration hearings and deporting them to corrupt regimes where they have no resources and do not speak the languages. Minnesota wouldn't have been invaded by masked fascists. The military would not have been gutted of competent officers nor denied minorities promotions.
I have no idea what would be happening in Gaza and the West Bank. Maybe the same thing. Maybe not. No one knows.
But if the idea is that you have a choice between more human misery and less human misery overall, isn't it our moral responsibility to vote for less misery?
Depends upon whom the misery is being inflicted, I suppose. If I have family in Palestine I am not going to vote for the candidate who supports sending weapons to the regime bent on wiping them out.
Had Harris won, her administration would likely notice that a growing portion of Democrats oppose further unconditional aid to Israel. No way to be sure but theres at least a chance she’d be pressuring Israel to stop the slaughter. With Trump, the only question is how many more Palestinians will die.
Maybe. Maybe not. If I am a voter for whom the issue of Gaza was paramount, all I saw was Biden falling all over himself to " stand with Israel" and Harris making no real effort to separate herself from that. I'm not voting for that.
Even if someone believed that Harris and Trump had the same position on Israel/Gaza, they were then morally obligated to consider the impact Trump would have on other vulnerable groups. Gutting foreign has killed an untold number of people. Citizens are dead because of the ICE invasions.
I understand, but the alternative was someone who is at least the same, but has turned out to be worse and began a campaign of killing Iranian civilians at Bibi's behest.
A very cogent argument against vote nihilism. I also like TBogg’s old argument that went something like: Every year the unicorns and fairies vote in Fantasyland for the purest most special fairy and then dance and sing; you don’t live there, grow the fuck up.
And by the way, thanks for that analysis of Carlin. Somebody should have pointed out to this guy that the half-educated confused with Mark Twain* that he, Carlin, was a performer and would get his book made no matter who was president. The rest of us had to live with decisions made by the uninformed.
Maybe it is nihilistic to continue to cling to "both parties on the same," but there is no better way to get Internet clout and clicks than that. Because now this is evidence in candidate quality; you have outright sadopopulist monsters that can run on the Republican line and there's no floor. Everyone in the American political spectrum just accepts this—the Max Millers of the world.
Democrats need to be perfect, Republicans only need *excuses* to get votes.
I understand the frustration for those of us who keep trying to pull the Democratic Party further leftward. We will undoubtedly never get exactly what we want. The Party is trying to appeal to what they consider "the center" to draw the most votes. I want the Party to advocate for what is the objectively correct position both morally and practically, regardless if that is supported by the majority of voters.
I also understand those who take the position that the Party will never improve if voters keep handing them their vote despite the Party's promotion of milk-toast candidates. We have to get their attention somehow.
But what I don't understand is the argument that not voting absolves the non-voter of responsibility, especially if that abdication results in objectively WORSE candidates and policies prevailing. A demonstration of purity fails completely when more people suffer because no candidate lived up to your standards. The candidates are never equally bad. One is always worse than the other. Policies have consequences.
The "both parties are the same" attitude tells me nothing other than the person spouting it is as easily influenced by propaganda as the most zealous FOX News watcher. It is objectively, obviously not true, and it's a line of propaganda that only benefits one party and they count on it working on liberals who claim to want a better world but are disinterested in doing any of the actual work. Boo on Morello, and I now also start to wonder if he's one of those guys who are all, "I'd vote for a woman, but not THAT woman..." (rinse and repeat on every woman candidate). Thank you for this piece, which reminds me again to never look to celebrities to provide a moral compass. Maybe Mister Rogers. But no one else.
Also, thank you for that elegant take down of Carlin's justification for why he didn't vote. Ugh.
This ridiculous "purity test" Democrats have to pass to get votes! Oh, so you didn't like Harris' policy on Palestine? I'll bet anything that it was better than trump's and that millions of Palentinians (as well as others in the Middle East and our own military) would be alive today if Harris had been in charge and told Bibi to fuck off; I'm also sure she wouldn't have given him genocidal free rein in the region. But oh, she leaned pro-Israel (I guess?) so toss out that entire vote for her, even though she was ready to implement policies and do what she could to make American lives better. Ace job, 𝑇𝑜𝑚 and everyone else who either felt that way or couldn't be bothered to vote for whatever reason. Jesus Christ, I live in ENGLAND and I still make sure I vote in my American elections!
I'm going to just note that if an issue is of paramount importance to you, "the lesser of the two evils" has no real meaning. If I have a choice between two candidates who both want to ban abortion across the board, I'm unlikely to vote for either of them no matter what else their positions. Frankly, then, I cannot condemn a voter of Palestinian origins for abstaining from voting for Harris. If that makes me a pariah in TPTG forum, then so be it.
I suppose my deep, dark secret had to come out some day, so.... I voted for John Anderson in 1980, but only because I couldn't bring myself to back either Carter or Reagan. But I'll never do it again, I promise! Cross my heart and hope to die...
What gets me is despite everything that has happened some people say the parties are the same. For them to believe that what the parties do has no effect on their life. They are most likely doing so well they can ignore a lot of things.
Excellent post. No notes SER.
PERFECT. THANK YOU.
The onus is on the candidate to not support genocide. Not on tom for having a principled stance of not voting for someone who is supporting it.
I voted for Harris. But it didn’t feel great. It felt selfish. But I do vote lesser two evils, it would just be nice to vote for something more.
Harris’ policy ideas were business as usual and crap, she made no break from Bidens atrocious support of genocide, she was sounding like a neo con while campaigning with them. And Boxed out Walz the last month to hang with republicans. Was talk she was catering to the likes of Mark Cuban and other crap billionaires and was gonna push out the incredible Lina Khan. All these were choices by the candidate.
So, how could you tell someone, hey vote this way, yea mass murder will happen but it’ll be less mass murder.
And yea, I’m fucking pissed the election went to the rapist insurrectionist. I’m mad that Harris ran a shit campaign, I’m mad that 77 mil voted for the orange POS. Hell, I’m even a mad at Tom, but also have a hard time articulating that anger, because how the hell could I be, when he couldn’t vote for continuing a genocide.
It’s a tough thing to deal with. My kids less safe. My parents less safe. Having hard time affording shit, fascism is here and it’s sick.
So I could stay mad at a Tom, or I could place my anger at those who actually hold power, who actually could be more and choose not to. And I will push on them to be better . To push for health care, education, climate change policy so we actually have future, abolishment of ICE, and holding this corrupt regime accountable for the corruption, death, and destruction. Push those and hold those who have their hands on the levers of power to account.
Or we can keep wasting time yelling at those who couldn’t talk themselves into voting for genocide.
Two things are true at the same time:
1) Democrats have to be better at winning over more voters and we should always push them to improve, because them losing to a party that had descended into nihilism is more than we can afford (this is no longer “losing to Dole’ after all)
2) As voters, we really have to make the best choice available even if we are unhappy with the alternatives. “Lesser of two evils” sounds bad but “letting the greater of two evils win” is obviously far worse.
Also, not voting never seems to cause the losing party to say “wow those people who didn’t vote for us had a point”. They just assume you were unmotivated and probably can’t be motivated. Showing up though—that does get noticed and pols do try to cater to their coalition. Be vocal with your criticism, help the better option win, and continue pressuring them after the election. Better yet, win over more converts, because pols read polls and they can do math.
I vote for Democrats, but I don't suffer under the delusion that they're going to do much more than slow down the slide into permanent Republican rule.
Between party leadership being quisling bastards and a huge chunk of the main body of the party listening to Republican outfits like third way and whatever consultants got hired this week I don't think this country is going anywhere but down.
Whether a country that used agent orange, white phosphorus, and dropped two nuclear bombs on civilian populations deserves to continue is a moral question in and of itself, and I'm on team "no, fuck that", but that's a different discussion entirely.
They refuse to admit their racism and sexism.
If Harris had won, we wouldn't have started a war with Iran. We wouldn't be arresting people at their immigration hearings and deporting them to corrupt regimes where they have no resources and do not speak the languages. Minnesota wouldn't have been invaded by masked fascists. The military would not have been gutted of competent officers nor denied minorities promotions.
I have no idea what would be happening in Gaza and the West Bank. Maybe the same thing. Maybe not. No one knows.
But if the idea is that you have a choice between more human misery and less human misery overall, isn't it our moral responsibility to vote for less misery?
Depends upon whom the misery is being inflicted, I suppose. If I have family in Palestine I am not going to vote for the candidate who supports sending weapons to the regime bent on wiping them out.
Had Harris won, her administration would likely notice that a growing portion of Democrats oppose further unconditional aid to Israel. No way to be sure but theres at least a chance she’d be pressuring Israel to stop the slaughter. With Trump, the only question is how many more Palestinians will die.
Maybe. Maybe not. If I am a voter for whom the issue of Gaza was paramount, all I saw was Biden falling all over himself to " stand with Israel" and Harris making no real effort to separate herself from that. I'm not voting for that.
Even if someone believed that Harris and Trump had the same position on Israel/Gaza, they were then morally obligated to consider the impact Trump would have on other vulnerable groups. Gutting foreign has killed an untold number of people. Citizens are dead because of the ICE invasions.
I understand, but the alternative was someone who is at least the same, but has turned out to be worse and began a campaign of killing Iranian civilians at Bibi's behest.
A very cogent argument against vote nihilism. I also like TBogg’s old argument that went something like: Every year the unicorns and fairies vote in Fantasyland for the purest most special fairy and then dance and sing; you don’t live there, grow the fuck up.
Thanks for this. Purity Ponies drive me nuts. I had a t-shirt made for the last election: “Political apathy isn’t debonair.”
And by the way, thanks for that analysis of Carlin. Somebody should have pointed out to this guy that the half-educated confused with Mark Twain* that he, Carlin, was a performer and would get his book made no matter who was president. The rest of us had to live with decisions made by the uninformed.
*who incidentally was political as fuck
Maybe it is nihilistic to continue to cling to "both parties on the same," but there is no better way to get Internet clout and clicks than that. Because now this is evidence in candidate quality; you have outright sadopopulist monsters that can run on the Republican line and there's no floor. Everyone in the American political spectrum just accepts this—the Max Millers of the world.
Democrats need to be perfect, Republicans only need *excuses* to get votes.
I understand the frustration for those of us who keep trying to pull the Democratic Party further leftward. We will undoubtedly never get exactly what we want. The Party is trying to appeal to what they consider "the center" to draw the most votes. I want the Party to advocate for what is the objectively correct position both morally and practically, regardless if that is supported by the majority of voters.
I also understand those who take the position that the Party will never improve if voters keep handing them their vote despite the Party's promotion of milk-toast candidates. We have to get their attention somehow.
But what I don't understand is the argument that not voting absolves the non-voter of responsibility, especially if that abdication results in objectively WORSE candidates and policies prevailing. A demonstration of purity fails completely when more people suffer because no candidate lived up to your standards. The candidates are never equally bad. One is always worse than the other. Policies have consequences.
The "both parties are the same" attitude tells me nothing other than the person spouting it is as easily influenced by propaganda as the most zealous FOX News watcher. It is objectively, obviously not true, and it's a line of propaganda that only benefits one party and they count on it working on liberals who claim to want a better world but are disinterested in doing any of the actual work. Boo on Morello, and I now also start to wonder if he's one of those guys who are all, "I'd vote for a woman, but not THAT woman..." (rinse and repeat on every woman candidate). Thank you for this piece, which reminds me again to never look to celebrities to provide a moral compass. Maybe Mister Rogers. But no one else.
Also, thank you for that elegant take down of Carlin's justification for why he didn't vote. Ugh.
This ridiculous "purity test" Democrats have to pass to get votes! Oh, so you didn't like Harris' policy on Palestine? I'll bet anything that it was better than trump's and that millions of Palentinians (as well as others in the Middle East and our own military) would be alive today if Harris had been in charge and told Bibi to fuck off; I'm also sure she wouldn't have given him genocidal free rein in the region. But oh, she leaned pro-Israel (I guess?) so toss out that entire vote for her, even though she was ready to implement policies and do what she could to make American lives better. Ace job, 𝑇𝑜𝑚 and everyone else who either felt that way or couldn't be bothered to vote for whatever reason. Jesus Christ, I live in ENGLAND and I still make sure I vote in my American elections!
I'm going to just note that if an issue is of paramount importance to you, "the lesser of the two evils" has no real meaning. If I have a choice between two candidates who both want to ban abortion across the board, I'm unlikely to vote for either of them no matter what else their positions. Frankly, then, I cannot condemn a voter of Palestinian origins for abstaining from voting for Harris. If that makes me a pariah in TPTG forum, then so be it.
I suppose my deep, dark secret had to come out some day, so.... I voted for John Anderson in 1980, but only because I couldn't bring myself to back either Carter or Reagan. But I'll never do it again, I promise! Cross my heart and hope to die...
So YOU’RE the one!
Insightful