What I'm saying is all the energy people had online for Mamdani, el-Sayed and Platner could've been used in boosting the challenger to Jeffries in the past cycle. "Establishment" money/AIPAC obviously isn't invincible, and even if a candidate is supported by the "establishment," good old online attention could be showered on them. Unless people believe that wouldn't work in his district or something is wrong with Jeffries' constituency and they wouldn't listen to the negatives about him?
Hell, people are outright saying Jeffries and Schumer work for Israel. And I will say again, that time Schumer got sick last year (violating the Don't Be Old, Don't Be Sick rule for Democrats), there was an opportunity to take the killshot and hound him out of office. There should've been the challengers crawling out of the woodwork just like they did to get rid of Joe Biden.
At this point I am team Van Hollen if only to finally squash this interminable argument.
Thank you for this essay. Jeffries lost me when he said he met with Jared Kushner in private and they discussed “affordability.” Seriously? I wasn’t born yesterday.
I’m so sick and tired of these politicians accepting the blatant corruption under the current administration, and pretending as if POTUS’s son-in-law has any business doing government work just because he feels like it.
Schumer comes from a time when Senate collegiality was still a thing, when Senators worked openly across party lines to support good legislation and made deals with each other. That is a thing of the past. Now the times call for a Senate leader who won't simply cave in negotiations to the opposition, and Schumer has not shown the ability to fight hard for what the vast majority of Democratic voters want.
I do not really think that Schumer will have much of a choice when 2028 comes around. His approval ratings are just so unbelievably awful that it seems plausible he could put the seat at risk by running again.
He is obviously arrogant as we are seeing with this leadership fight but I do not see how a senator with a 33% approval rating in his own state can expect to retain power.
He used to be super popular in New York, even having positive favorable ratings amongst Republicans as late as 2016!
You're definitely right in that it was the voters and trump/MAGA, more than Jeffries and Schumer, who facilitated the landslide victory to the Democrats. Schumer was always backing the wrong horse and Jeffries...well, I still remember that time he met with Kushner and I STILL don't know what that was all about.
I just don't see either of them as the fighters we need in the coming years (especially the next two). Jeffries seems too wimpy and Schumer just seems like he's in another timeline where sternly-worded letter will suffice.
Van Halen is running for the majority leader! (Flips hair, throws goat.) Schumer has to go. He's got no feist. BTW, be polite to Boomers or they'll leave it all to the cat. You think we won't? (Actually, I'm a Buster, but I sometimes caucus with Boomers, as long as they don't go anti-vax or, like the co-founder of Burning Man yesterday, repost a fallacious Cleese screed about Muslim atrocities that, rather than being noble truth telling, was exactly the talk Col. Flashman would have heard from his fellow officers 130 years ago.)
Jeffries is better than Schumer, because during the last budget showdown he held his team together while Schumer (who made clear he wasn’t a fan of the showdown at all) wound up caving for nothing. Jeffries I get the sense tries to reflect his caucus, for better or worse. He’s also younger, which should mean something. And Republicans simply can’t as easily use him in their ads to scare away voters (yes, he’s black, but good luck trying to make that guy look scary—just picture that unintentionally hilarious photo of him holding the baseball bat).
Schumer though is completely washed up. Not just his age, but his way of thinking is calcified in the last century. He’s another Boomer who wants to hold onto power at the expense of everything he claimed to fight for (remember RBG? Amy Coney Barret sure does!). He exudes weakness, has zero leverage with disloyal bags of shit like Fetterman or Sinema, no leverage with red state unicorns like Manchin, his spirit animals are weak reeds like Kaine and Durbin. Nearly blowing it with his Michigan and Maine picks demonstrate his total misread of candidates. He has no strategic acumen, consistently voting for Trump nominees as though the Fairy of Civility is going to give him a cookie. And his very personal exudes “old Wall Street New Yorker who is selling your debt to a collection agency.” Republicans are happy to feature him in their ads.
Good analysis of both men. Something that others had pointed out - both Jeffries and Schumer are from NYC, and the same borough - Brooklyn. The president and the VP can't be from the same state, which is a good idea. The leaders of both houses of Congress shouldn't be either, even if the Constitution doesn't forbid it. In this case, it's not just the same state, but the same city. At least one must not be the Dem leader, and it would be better that Schumer is the one to go.
Speaking as a Boomer, I'm sick and tired of Boomer politicians letting their egos get in the way of progress.
The New York thing isn't great! It’d be one thing if the Empire State was the future of the party and country, but it’s not—population is shifting south and west and the Democrats of NY are running a pretty dysfunctional system, rotted through with an old boys network with traces of Tammany Hall (one reason it was such a shock to them for AOC to unseat Crowley—in a more dynamic state it’d have been anticipated as a normal outsider challenge). And much of that “let’s cut a deal with our good faith Republican friends who are totally normal” outlook comes from decades of dealing with NY Republicans who for a long time were pretty normal (less so these days, see Stefanik’s heel turn, and Claudia Tenney).
I’d be fine with a Boomer if they truly were top notch, but Schumer is a relic of the 1996 world, where the opposition was people like Bob Dole and Clinton could win southern states because his country fried persona never fit the “eastern elitist” image Republicans tried to paint him with.
I'm not a fan of either man, really, but I am more inclined to give Jeffries a pass than Schumer. Jeffries is presiding over a large group of ideologically diverse lawmakers, some from bright blue socialist friendly districts, others from ones Trump won by 20 points. He simply *has* to be more ideologically flexible than the online mobs want him to be if he wants to hold his caucus together. Hopefully in short time he can be dragged to the left on some current Dem priorities.
Schumer is another story. He's given us a ton of evidence his political radar is stuck in 1992, and he seems simply out of step with the views of the modern Democratic party. It's worth a look at the ones who are backing him (including my own state's most prominent fossil, Angus King) vs the ones backing Van Hollen, who is no spring chicken himself (67) but seems more inclined to take advantage of what could be an enormous step forward for the Democratic party.
I also don't think two leaders from one state is a really good idea, but that is a secondary concern. So I'll be watching this with interest.
Schumer has to go and there needs to be mandatory retirement age too. These people get ensconced and then appear to do nothing.
Wish we could get Schumer and Jeffries to read and take your piece to heart. But wish in one hand and…
By that sports logic, Schumer should have been fired after the 2024 election.
What I'm saying is all the energy people had online for Mamdani, el-Sayed and Platner could've been used in boosting the challenger to Jeffries in the past cycle. "Establishment" money/AIPAC obviously isn't invincible, and even if a candidate is supported by the "establishment," good old online attention could be showered on them. Unless people believe that wouldn't work in his district or something is wrong with Jeffries' constituency and they wouldn't listen to the negatives about him?
Hell, people are outright saying Jeffries and Schumer work for Israel. And I will say again, that time Schumer got sick last year (violating the Don't Be Old, Don't Be Sick rule for Democrats), there was an opportunity to take the killshot and hound him out of office. There should've been the challengers crawling out of the woodwork just like they did to get rid of Joe Biden.
At this point I am team Van Hollen if only to finally squash this interminable argument.
Thank you for this essay. Jeffries lost me when he said he met with Jared Kushner in private and they discussed “affordability.” Seriously? I wasn’t born yesterday.
I’m so sick and tired of these politicians accepting the blatant corruption under the current administration, and pretending as if POTUS’s son-in-law has any business doing government work just because he feels like it.
Schumer comes from a time when Senate collegiality was still a thing, when Senators worked openly across party lines to support good legislation and made deals with each other. That is a thing of the past. Now the times call for a Senate leader who won't simply cave in negotiations to the opposition, and Schumer has not shown the ability to fight hard for what the vast majority of Democratic voters want.
Bring on the fight!
I do not really think that Schumer will have much of a choice when 2028 comes around. His approval ratings are just so unbelievably awful that it seems plausible he could put the seat at risk by running again.
He is obviously arrogant as we are seeing with this leadership fight but I do not see how a senator with a 33% approval rating in his own state can expect to retain power.
He used to be super popular in New York, even having positive favorable ratings amongst Republicans as late as 2016!
I'm not happy with Jeffries, but I want to see Schumer launched into the sun.
You're definitely right in that it was the voters and trump/MAGA, more than Jeffries and Schumer, who facilitated the landslide victory to the Democrats. Schumer was always backing the wrong horse and Jeffries...well, I still remember that time he met with Kushner and I STILL don't know what that was all about.
I just don't see either of them as the fighters we need in the coming years (especially the next two). Jeffries seems too wimpy and Schumer just seems like he's in another timeline where sternly-worded letter will suffice.
Van Halen is running for the majority leader! (Flips hair, throws goat.) Schumer has to go. He's got no feist. BTW, be polite to Boomers or they'll leave it all to the cat. You think we won't? (Actually, I'm a Buster, but I sometimes caucus with Boomers, as long as they don't go anti-vax or, like the co-founder of Burning Man yesterday, repost a fallacious Cleese screed about Muslim atrocities that, rather than being noble truth telling, was exactly the talk Col. Flashman would have heard from his fellow officers 130 years ago.)
There’s a lot of Boomers who follow SER, just sayin’.
Jeffries is better than Schumer, because during the last budget showdown he held his team together while Schumer (who made clear he wasn’t a fan of the showdown at all) wound up caving for nothing. Jeffries I get the sense tries to reflect his caucus, for better or worse. He’s also younger, which should mean something. And Republicans simply can’t as easily use him in their ads to scare away voters (yes, he’s black, but good luck trying to make that guy look scary—just picture that unintentionally hilarious photo of him holding the baseball bat).
Schumer though is completely washed up. Not just his age, but his way of thinking is calcified in the last century. He’s another Boomer who wants to hold onto power at the expense of everything he claimed to fight for (remember RBG? Amy Coney Barret sure does!). He exudes weakness, has zero leverage with disloyal bags of shit like Fetterman or Sinema, no leverage with red state unicorns like Manchin, his spirit animals are weak reeds like Kaine and Durbin. Nearly blowing it with his Michigan and Maine picks demonstrate his total misread of candidates. He has no strategic acumen, consistently voting for Trump nominees as though the Fairy of Civility is going to give him a cookie. And his very personal exudes “old Wall Street New Yorker who is selling your debt to a collection agency.” Republicans are happy to feature him in their ads.
Good analysis of both men. Something that others had pointed out - both Jeffries and Schumer are from NYC, and the same borough - Brooklyn. The president and the VP can't be from the same state, which is a good idea. The leaders of both houses of Congress shouldn't be either, even if the Constitution doesn't forbid it. In this case, it's not just the same state, but the same city. At least one must not be the Dem leader, and it would be better that Schumer is the one to go.
Speaking as a Boomer, I'm sick and tired of Boomer politicians letting their egos get in the way of progress.
The New York thing isn't great! It’d be one thing if the Empire State was the future of the party and country, but it’s not—population is shifting south and west and the Democrats of NY are running a pretty dysfunctional system, rotted through with an old boys network with traces of Tammany Hall (one reason it was such a shock to them for AOC to unseat Crowley—in a more dynamic state it’d have been anticipated as a normal outsider challenge). And much of that “let’s cut a deal with our good faith Republican friends who are totally normal” outlook comes from decades of dealing with NY Republicans who for a long time were pretty normal (less so these days, see Stefanik’s heel turn, and Claudia Tenney).
I’d be fine with a Boomer if they truly were top notch, but Schumer is a relic of the 1996 world, where the opposition was people like Bob Dole and Clinton could win southern states because his country fried persona never fit the “eastern elitist” image Republicans tried to paint him with.
Jeffries did lead the Democrats’ united response when a desperate Trump started a redistricting war to keep the House under GOP control.
Maybe I'm misremembering, but wasn't that Gavin leading that fight?
Schumer might find it hard to resist leading a sizable Senate majority under a Democratic president.
Yeah, but to do what? An incremental tax break? He won't get behind anything his friends, the Baileys, don't approve of.
I'm not a fan of either man, really, but I am more inclined to give Jeffries a pass than Schumer. Jeffries is presiding over a large group of ideologically diverse lawmakers, some from bright blue socialist friendly districts, others from ones Trump won by 20 points. He simply *has* to be more ideologically flexible than the online mobs want him to be if he wants to hold his caucus together. Hopefully in short time he can be dragged to the left on some current Dem priorities.
Schumer is another story. He's given us a ton of evidence his political radar is stuck in 1992, and he seems simply out of step with the views of the modern Democratic party. It's worth a look at the ones who are backing him (including my own state's most prominent fossil, Angus King) vs the ones backing Van Hollen, who is no spring chicken himself (67) but seems more inclined to take advantage of what could be an enormous step forward for the Democratic party.
I also don't think two leaders from one state is a really good idea, but that is a secondary concern. So I'll be watching this with interest.