Discussion about this post

User's avatar
BrandoG's avatar

Jeffries is better than Schumer, because during the last budget showdown he held his team together while Schumer (who made clear he wasn’t a fan of the showdown at all) wound up caving for nothing. Jeffries I get the sense tries to reflect his caucus, for better or worse. He’s also younger, which should mean something. And Republicans simply can’t as easily use him in their ads to scare away voters (yes, he’s black, but good luck trying to make that guy look scary—just picture that unintentionally hilarious photo of him holding the baseball bat).

Schumer though is completely washed up. Not just his age, but his way of thinking is calcified in the last century. He’s another Boomer who wants to hold onto power at the expense of everything he claimed to fight for (remember RBG? Amy Coney Barret sure does!). He exudes weakness, has zero leverage with disloyal bags of shit like Fetterman or Sinema, no leverage with red state unicorns like Manchin, his spirit animals are weak reeds like Kaine and Durbin. Nearly blowing it with his Michigan and Maine picks demonstrate his total misread of candidates. He has no strategic acumen, consistently voting for Trump nominees as though the Fairy of Civility is going to give him a cookie. And his very personal exudes “old Wall Street New Yorker who is selling your debt to a collection agency.” Republicans are happy to feature him in their ads.

Late Blooming's avatar

I'm not a fan of either man, really, but I am more inclined to give Jeffries a pass than Schumer. Jeffries is presiding over a large group of ideologically diverse lawmakers, some from bright blue socialist friendly districts, others from ones Trump won by 20 points. He simply *has* to be more ideologically flexible than the online mobs want him to be if he wants to hold his caucus together. Hopefully in short time he can be dragged to the left on some current Dem priorities.

Schumer is another story. He's given us a ton of evidence his political radar is stuck in 1992, and he seems simply out of step with the views of the modern Democratic party. It's worth a look at the ones who are backing him (including my own state's most prominent fossil, Angus King) vs the ones backing Van Hollen, who is no spring chicken himself (67) but seems more inclined to take advantage of what could be an enormous step forward for the Democratic party.

I also don't think two leaders from one state is a really good idea, but that is a secondary concern. So I'll be watching this with interest.

14 more comments...

Ready for more?