Discussion about this post

User's avatar
BrandoG's avatar

I recall in a previous post you made a good point about how the story was also one of friendship in how his old partner Marley, now a doomed ghost, wanted to warn Scrooge rather than have him share the same fate. An origin story that explores their friendship would have been interesting.

Also, one could make Scrooge more sympathetic and complex by focusing on his love for his sister, whose death he blamed on her son. Maybe show how his fear of becoming poor animated him to such a point it ruined his human connections and rather than face up to that it made him more miserly, using his miserly nature as a crutch to rationalize not engaging with other people, when the truth is he was insecure about being hurt. Maybe knowing that Cratchit had a loving family fueled his resentment of him. A story like that could explain why he was able to have a redemption arc in a single night—it was in him all along, he just needed a push.

Late Blooming's avatar

My favorite version is most people's favorite: the 1951 Alistair Sim version. No Scrooge was ever redeemed so joyously, LOL. And bless Charles Dickens, a social justice warrior of his time who wielded his pen the way other men wielded their armies.

8 more comments...

Ready for more?