Johnny Depp’s big comeback vehicle is the just released Ebenezer, a Christmas Carol adaptation we didn’t ask for but are getting anyway. This version, directed by Ti West with a screenplay by Nathaniel Halpern, is advertised as a “dark Gothic horror fantasy.” Charles Dickens’s classic is indeed a ghost story but the sort you could tell to children gathered around the fire without giving them nightmares. An overtly scary and macabre Christmas Carol adaptation seems to miss the point, and it doesn’t end there.
Ebenezer offers a new, grimmer motivation for Scrooge’s miserly condition. Depp’s Ebenezer is traumatized after his kindly boss, Mr. Fezziwig, is viciously stabbed to death by a homeless man. Yes, Ebenezer Scrooge is given a John Wick origin story. Ben Shapiro would approve.
Nowhere in Dickens’ actual text are London’s struggling and less fortunate depicted as a threat to the public. He never suggests that any of them have it coming. The poor and destitute are more often presented as the city’s beating heart. Even the desperate scavengers who sell Scrooge’s belongings do so after he’s dead and no one gives a damn.
When a young Scrooge’s love Belle confronts his hardened nature, she doesn’t suggest that rampant homelessness, violent crime, and migrant caravans have radicalized him:
“It matters little,” she said, softly. “To you, very little. Another idol has displaced me; and if it can cheer and comfort you in time to come, as I would have tried to do, I have no just cause to grieve.”
“What Idol has displaced you?” he rejoined.
“A golden one.”
“This is the even-handed dealing of the world!” he said. “There is nothing on which it is so hard as poverty; and there is nothing it professes to condemn with such severity as the pursuit of wealth!”
“You fear the world too much,” she answered, gently. “All your other hopes have merged into the hope of being beyond the chance of its sordid reproach. I have seen your nobler aspirations fall off one by one, until the master-passion, Gain, engrosses you. Have I not?”
Scrooge doesn’t fear the poor. He fears becoming poor himself, and his contempt for the less fortunate is borne out of that fear, which has shackled him. Consider Scrooge’s response to the men collecting for the poor on Christmas Eve:
“Are there no prisons?” asked Scrooge.
“Plenty of prisons,” said the gentleman, laying down the pen again.
“And the Union workhouses?” demanded Scrooge. “Are they still in operation?”
“They are. Still,” returned the gentleman, “I wish I could say they were not.”
“The Treadmill and the Poor Law are in full vigour, then?” said Scrooge.
“Both very busy, sir.”
“Oh! I was afraid, from what you said at first, that something had occurred to stop them in their useful course,” said Scrooge. “I’m very glad to hear it.”
Dickens has Scrooge express sentiments that were disturbingly commonplace during Dickens’ time (and ours). “Social reformers” such as Jeremy Bentham argued that the handing out food and temporary shelter to everyone who needs them would only encourage poverty.
The Poor Law Amendment Act of 1834 was intended to put an end to the “dole.” The supposed “able-bodied” poor would only receive help in at the union workhouse. This sounds very familiar to the GOP’s demand for “work requirements” before the poor are deemed deserving enough for assistance.
The gentleman reacts strongly to the “union workhouses,” because when Dickens wrote A Christmas Carol, they had become a refuge for the elderly, sick, and disabled — likely where Tiny Tim would’ve wound up even if he’d lived. These were obviously not people the government should press into backbreaking service for a few scraps of bread.
The “treadmill” was an “everlasting staircase” that prisoners walked on for hours each day with straps and weights attached to provide resistance. This was intended to teach the “idle” poor “habits of industry.” It presumably worked wonders for their calf muscles before they died from exhaustion.
The “Poor Law” addressed the problem of “vagrants and beggars,” but a decade prior to A Christmas Carol’s publication, the Poor Law Amendment Act overhauled the system to appeal to voters like Scrooge. The needy could only receive assistance within a workhouse, where the conditions were deliberately miserable so as to discourage people from going. That puts one of Scrooge’s more infamous lines in an even harsher context:
“I wish to be left alone,” said Scrooge. “Since you ask me what I wish, gentlemen, that is my answer. I don’t make merry myself at Christmas and I can’t afford to make idle people merry. I help to support the establishments I have mentioned—they cost enough; and those who are badly off must go there.”
“Many can’t go there; and many would rather die.”
“If they would rather die,” said Scrooge, “they had better do it, and decrease the surplus population.”
Most stage and screen adaptations end here, but in the book, Scrooge adds feebly that he “doesn’t know” that people would rather die than go to the workhouses, even when they are structured by design to ensure just that.
(I suppose a spoiler warning is necessary, but the charity collectors — genuinely kind men in Dickens’s story — are actually crooks in Ebenezer. It’s as if Ayn Rand wrote this script.)
West has said that his Scrooge uses logic and convincing arguments against others: “As his Scrooge cuts someone down verbally or as he makes a financial point or withdraws, you do understand why he’s doing it.”
However, Dickens never intended for Scrooge to make “good arguments” based in sound logic. He’s a “covetous, old sinner” parroting the words of cruel selfish men, the Victorian version of someone who watches too much Fox News.
English economist Thomas Malthus believed poverty and starvation weren’t just unavoidable — rather than a deliberate outcome of the period’s rampant income inequality — but necessary. Society can’t provide for everyone, so why bother: Death would remove the “undesirables” from the population. Anyone who couldn’t sustain themselves from help didn’t deserve to live. (Malthus himself could’ve benefited from a ghostly intervention.)
Malthus argued that “preventive checks,” such as moral restraint, delayed marriage, and celibacy, would limit population growth and keep the poor in limited supply. Scrooge had sneered at Bob Cratchit, who earns “15 schillings a week” (about 600 pounds today), marrying and having five kids, all of whom with limited economic prospects. In both Scrooge and Matlhus’s eyes, Cratchit’s miserable existence selects his lack of “moral restraint.”
A redeemed Scrooge raises Cratchit’s salary in recognition of his personal need. Republicans today sneer at the liberal assertion that every job deserves a “living wage.” They’d insist that a 21st Century Bob Cratchit chose to have a big family, including a sick kid, and that’s his personal problem not his employer’s. Scrooge should just hire a student intern.
Of course, today’s Republicans always sound more like Scrooge than humble lowercase Christ. Pre-reformation Scrooge at least is no hypocrite. He offers no Christian charity on the holiday but he doesn’t indulge in Christmas cheer, either. He could have enjoyed a hearty meal and a cozy fire at his nephew Fred’s house, while leaving Bob Cratchit to suffer in silent poverty. Too many people today think they are better than Scrooge simply because they deck the halls, sing carols, and otherwise celebrate their own good fortune while conveniently forgetting those who are without.
Later, Scrooge is an unseen visitor at the Cratchit family Christmas. Their own humanity stokes the dying embers within his soul, but when he expresses concern for Tiny Tim, the Ghost of Christmas Present turns Scrooge’s callous words against him. (Watch below this clip from the George C. Scott version, which first aired on December 17, 1984.)
“If these shadows remain unaltered by the Future, none other of my race,” returned the Ghost, “will find him here. What then? If he be like to die, he had better do it, and decrease the surplus population.”
Scrooge hung his head to hear his own words quoted by the Spirit, and was overcome with penitence and grief.
“Man,” said the Ghost, “if man you be in heart, not adamant, forbear that wicked cant until you have discovered What the surplus is, and Where it is. Will you decide what men shall live, what men shall die? It may be, that in the sight of Heaven, you are more worthless and less fit to live than millions like this poor man’s child. Oh God! to hear the Insect on the leaf pronouncing on the too much life among his hungry brothers in the dust!”
In the 1984 adaptation, Edward Woodard’s Ghost of Christmas Present didn’t hide his contempt for Scrooge. He forces him to confront more of the “surplus population,” those whose Christmas Day is spent without the comfort of even a meager dwelling. “What does it have to do with me?” Scrooge asks, and a furious Present bellows, “Are they not of the human race!”
Marley’s ghost tells Scrooge, “Why did I walk through crowds of fellow-beings with my eyes turned down, and never raise them to that blessed Star which led the Wise Men to a poor abode! Were there no poor homes to which its light would have conducted me!”
Ebenezer Scrooge abandoned his fellow travelers in this life, viewing them all as suckers or parasites. Nothing justified his cruelty and cynicism. That’s what makes his redemption so transformative and uplifting. Any adaptation of A Christmas Carol that doesn’t understand this isn’t worth your time. Avoid Johnny Depp’s Ebenezer and, instead, go watch Sir Patrick Stewart in 1999’s A Christmas Carol.



I recall in a previous post you made a good point about how the story was also one of friendship in how his old partner Marley, now a doomed ghost, wanted to warn Scrooge rather than have him share the same fate. An origin story that explores their friendship would have been interesting.
Also, one could make Scrooge more sympathetic and complex by focusing on his love for his sister, whose death he blamed on her son. Maybe show how his fear of becoming poor animated him to such a point it ruined his human connections and rather than face up to that it made him more miserly, using his miserly nature as a crutch to rationalize not engaging with other people, when the truth is he was insecure about being hurt. Maybe knowing that Cratchit had a loving family fueled his resentment of him. A story like that could explain why he was able to have a redemption arc in a single night—it was in him all along, he just needed a push.
My favorite version is most people's favorite: the 1951 Alistair Sim version. No Scrooge was ever redeemed so joyously, LOL. And bless Charles Dickens, a social justice warrior of his time who wielded his pen the way other men wielded their armies.