10 Comments
User's avatar
llamaspit's avatar

I'm going to stick with my annual re-watching of "Scrooged", the version with Bill Murray playing a heartless entertainment company executive, very much like the Ellisons. It's wildly funny, and heartfelt, and conveys the message of Christmas very much as did the Dickens original story.

Old Man Shadow's avatar

Ah... released by Paramount. Of course it was. The Ellison's propaganda factory. No wonder they made A MAGA Christmas Carol.

Barbara's avatar

The more I hear about this new version, the more disinclined I am to give them my money. PS: I truly love the George C Scott production.

Myra Donnelley's avatar

My Christmas Carol of choice is, of course, the Mr. Maroon version.

SethTriggs's avatar

This current version is surely propaganda meant to make people feel good about their support of cruelty to those without means.

Thanks and I know I shall not be seeing it.

Myra Donnelley's avatar

A sound and marvelous recommendation.

I once toyed with an “adaptation” of a Christmas Carol for Portland's Stark Raving Theatre, that began with an affluent businessman led by a young prostitute into an alley piled with garbage where the businessman was robbed and brutally beaten by a male accomplice and the prostitute. As the businessman (a “surrogate” for the relatively affluent theater audience) is left bleeding and unconscious on the ground, there is a rustle and movement, and the garbage bags are revealed to be the “clothing” of a group of houseless people. (This was an homage to “Sally”, the houseless woman who spent many a daytime under the awning of my apartment building on West 28th Street in Manhattan.) They tuck a couple of dirty blankets around the unconscious man and by the light of a trashcan fire enact the story of a Christmas Carol. Eventually (after Marley's visit in the tale), the man appears to start to recover sufficiently to participate in the tale and share in some food and water. The play, after Scrooge's/the businessman's Christmas morning epiphany that where there is life, there is hope”, ended with flashing red and blue lights, the houseless people vanish back into a pile of “garbage bags”, the businessman is once again unconscious, but has been kept warm under a pile of dirty blankets, near a scattering of plastic bottles and food wrappers. A young policeman, drawn by the light of the trashcan fire sees the body and calls in a suspected homicide. But as he bends down and draws near to check, he cries out, “There's a pulse! He has a pulse!” Curtain.

I was , of course, told that adaptation was “too cynical” for the holidays, even for Stark Raving which was not exactly known for light, comedic fare.

Linda1961 aka Pollyanna's avatar

Thanks for this, so I know to give Johnny Deppp's "Ebenezer" a hard pass. Sir Patrick Stewart's "A Christmas Carol" is a much better choice. Or any of the other versions, or just read the story.

Cheryl from Maryland's avatar

Thanks for reinforcing my thoughts on NOT seeing "Ebeneezer". Also, thanks for highlighting my two favorite versions of "A Christmas Carol": the 1999 version with Sir Patrick Stewart and George C. Scott's performance in 1984. I have always wept, and wept this am, seeing Stewart with the Ghost of Christmas Past (the great Joel Gray). Sir Patrick alternates between a deep longing for the joy and love he felt in his youth, with hints of knowledge that he threw away true happiness. Afterwards, we see his anger at the Ghost for reviving tenderer feelings and for challenging the man he has become (culminating in Scrooge snuffing out the Ghost to try to make it all go away).

Late Blooming's avatar

My favorite version is most people's favorite: the 1951 Alistair Sim version. No Scrooge was ever redeemed so joyously, LOL. And bless Charles Dickens, a social justice warrior of his time who wielded his pen the way other men wielded their armies.

BrandoG's avatar

I recall in a previous post you made a good point about how the story was also one of friendship in how his old partner Marley, now a doomed ghost, wanted to warn Scrooge rather than have him share the same fate. An origin story that explores their friendship would have been interesting.

Also, one could make Scrooge more sympathetic and complex by focusing on his love for his sister, whose death he blamed on her son. Maybe show how his fear of becoming poor animated him to such a point it ruined his human connections and rather than face up to that it made him more miserly, using his miserly nature as a crutch to rationalize not engaging with other people, when the truth is he was insecure about being hurt. Maybe knowing that Cratchit had a loving family fueled his resentment of him. A story like that could explain why he was able to have a redemption arc in a single night—it was in him all along, he just needed a push.