On January 6, Remembering The Successful Right-Wing Insurrection Of 1876
Donald Trump follows in the same path as South Carolina Gov. Wade Hampton.
Today marks the first January 6 of Donald Trump’s second term. It’s a somewhat awkward anniversary to say the least. Five years ago, Trump’s mob waged an “unprecedented” attack on the Capitol, and now, Trump occupies the White House — not because his first coup was successful but because American voters freely returned him to power in 2024. It’s a grim ending to the U.S. democracy’s fairy tale.
However, there is significant historical precedent for the events of January 6 and its aftermath. The less-than United States has always had a tenuous relationship with freedom and democracy.
Another past insurrection that proved quite successful occurred in my home state of South Carolina. After the Civil War, former Confederate general and enslaver Wade Hampton actively opposed Reconstruction and any participation in politics from newly freed Black people. He laid low for the next decade, biding his time, but after the U.S. government started enforcing anti-Klan legislation in 1870 and 1871, he raised money for their legal defense funds. This should recall how Trump and the GOP soon embraced January 6 criminals, even calling them “hostages.”
Many white Southerners had formed “rifle clubs” (wink, wink) after the Civil War that swiftly grew to as many as 20,000 members. Political campaigns became increasingly violent. Hampton led the Redeemers, a political coalition of Southern conservatives who sought to reclaim political power and enforce white supremacy. They undermined and suppressed the liberal vote through violence and threats of violence. By 1876, just six years after Black men gained the right to vote, Louisiana, South Carolina, and Florida were the only Southern states left “unredeemed” (i.e. restored to white rule). Rutherford B. Hayes, a Union general and one-time abolitionist, agreed to withdraw federal troops and abandon Black Southerners in exchange for the presidency. I imagine John Fetterman would approve of Hayes’ “bipartisanship.”
Prominent supporters of Wade Hampton’s gubernatorial campaign were the Red Shirts, a white supremacist terror group considered the paramilitary arm of the white conservative South. Their name was a mocking reference to the so-called “bloody shirt” speech from Sen. Oliver P. Morton, a close ally of Abraham Lincoln’s, denouncing violence inflicted on Northern soldiers and so-called “carpet baggers.” The speech was intended to appeal to their humanity, but instead racist thugs started proudly wearing red shirts as a symbol of defiance and resistance for white conservatives in South Carolina (who then identified themselves with the Democratic Party). They’ve always loved owning the libs. Nice white ladies sewed red flannel shirts and other red garments. They even wore red ribbons in their hair or around their waists. Young men who were too young to fight in the Civil War wore red shirts to show that the Confederacy still endured.
Red Shirts actively intimidated Black voters and any white voters who weren’t on the right side politically. They were especially active in the states where Black people were the majority. They crashed political meetings, disrupted organizing efforts, and terrorized Black voters to keep them from the ballot box. Black citizens had the franchise for barely a decade but stopped voting from fear, and others were coerced into voting for white conservative politicians (then Democrats) under pressure.
In South Carolina counties not far from where I grew up, Black men who dared vote were driven from their homes and whipped, and many Black political leaders were murdered. It’s important to note that in 1870, Black people made up at least 58.6 percent of South Carolina’s population. My home could’ve become Wakanda, but true democracy is often helpless against violent fascism, as I fear we might soon learn again.
During the 1876 elections, white conservatives in the state voted "early and often,” while the Black vote was violently suppressed. Wade Hampton’s path to the governor’s mansion was especially bloody. Nicholas Lehman, in his book Redemption: The Last Battle of the Civil War, estimated that 150 Black South Carolinians were murdered during Hampton’s campaign.
Hampton’s thugs didn’t just suppress the Black vote, they artificially inflated the white vote in Laurens and Edgefield counties, where the vote counts comically exceeded the total population. Both Hampton and incumbent governor Daniel Henry Chamberlain claimed victory in the election, and after six months — during which Hampton negotiated behind the scenes for the removal of federal troops — the South Carolina Supreme Court declared Hampton the winner. This made him the first former Confederate to regain power in the state since the Civil War.
Chamberlain had supported civil rights. Hampton obviously did not, and Jim Crow soon jumped all over the backs of the “free” Black population. White conservatives called Hampton the “Savior of South Carolina” who’d made their state great again.
Hampton was re-elected in 1878 with Red Shirt support but less violence than last time. Black people had learned a bitter lesson. Two days after the election, Hampton was thrown from a mule while deer hunting and broke his right leg, which was later amputated due to complications. That one-legged bastard still inflicted hell on Black people — not that history accounts for this. The South Carolina state encyclopedia’s entry on Wade Hampton states that his “administration was characterized by honesty, fiscal conservatism, and attempts at cooperation across racial and party lines.” Meanwhile, South Carolina’s “Black codes” required Black “servants” to work from dawn to dusk while maintaining round-the-clock smiles. Black people were forbidden from taking any job other than laborer unless able to pay a $100 fee (almost $2,000 in today’s money).
Now, Black people in Greenville, South Carolina, drive on Wade Hampton Boulevard and their kids attend Wade Hampton High School. Unfortunately, despite many Americans’ most fervent hopes, Trump and MAGA are not historical outliers. It seems as if Trump will enjoy a similar fate as Wade Hampton, though with access to modern medicine.
Of course, Trump didn’t need another violent coup to reclaim office. America was surrendered to him during a time of peace and relative prosperity. The full scope of what happened on January 6 will soon fade from the public’s notoriously shoddy memory. Fox News journalist Charles Gasparino dismissed January 6 as merely a “protest that went badly sideways” where the only casualty was one of Trump’s misguided supporters. This is an obvious lie: Cops were beaten holding off Trump’s mob, and a few died afterward. Far more were left traumatized. Yet, the police unions still supported Trump last year, which only emboldens such lies.
Like the Daughters of the Confederacy, the Republican-controlled House of Representatives plan to rewrite history with their own “investigations” into January 6. Last year, House Speaker Mike Johnson said GOP leaders would create their own January 6 select committee that would investigate the original January 6 select committee.
“House Republicans are proud of our work so far in exposing the false narratives peddled by the politically motivated January 6 Select Committee during the 117th Congress, but there is clearly more work to be done,” Johnson said.
It probably won’t take that much work to peddle conspiracy theories blaming the January 6 Capitol attack on Nancy Pelosi, Liz Cheney, or far-left leprechauns.
Trump predictably spent much of his first year seeking vengeance against anyone who stood against him. He pardoned convicted January 6 rioters while waging a “campaign of retribution” against FBI agents who worked with Special Counsel Jack Smith’s team or simply considered insufficiently “loyal” to his regime.
No blood was shed when Trump reclaimed power, but this January 6 remains a dark day that the light of truth has failed to penetrate.
I hang my head in shame and heartbreak because it seems that we will never learn. What a grand disservice we do to our society only because “not white” and turn away from progress that can be made by listening to smarter voices that may be a different color. No other reason than myopic self serving and power. Dumb dumb dumb.
On July 12, 2022, the United States House Select Committee to Investigate the January 6th Attack on the United States Capitol publicly named the following as Congressional leaders of the Republican Insurrection:
Brian Babin (R – TX);
Andy Biggs (R – AZ);
Matt Gaetz (R – FL);
Louie Gohmert (R – TX);
Marjorie Taylor Greene (R – GA);
Andy Harris (R – MD);
Jody Hice (R – GA);
Jim Jordan (R – OH);
Scott Perry (R – PA).
Not one of these Republicans has been charged or prosecuted for sedition or treason.