Democrats have branded themselves as the “pro-democracy” party in the decade since Donald Trump’s first election. Yet, far too many Democrats treat “pro-democracy” as a slogan and chafe at actual democracy in practice. Consider the uproar when a significant number of Democratic voters demanded a change in congressional leadership. This was treated as a personal affront: “How dare you ingrates speak this way about Hakeem Jeffries and Chuck Schumer, who delivered this massive Democratic midterm victory?” Of course, that misses the fact that it’s the voters themselves — who gave Democrats their money, time, and support — who truly helped carry the day. Then, I suppose you can give credit to Trump’s own ego-driven stupidity, who tanked the economy and started a needless war, which helped give Democrats an opening in Texas, Ohio, Kansas, Iowa, South Carolina, and Mississippi. Jeffries and Schumer didn’t unveil some innovative, master plan for flipping states Trump carried in 2024 by double digits. They simply pointed at the flames and said they’d consider dousing them.
A persistent Schumer talking point is that it’s unwise and downright unfair to replace the “manager” who took his team to the Super Bowl or the World Series. This isn’t a compelling argument, because we’re not talking about sports but democracy, where citizens regularly vote for their leaders. Even if they’re doing a great job, you don’t just cancel elections.
I believe actual, real elections for speaker of the House and Senate leader should be normalized and not treated as coup attempts. The speaker of the House is second in line to the presidency but just 125,196 people actually voted for Jeffries in the most recent election. That also wasn’t an affirmative vote for Jeffries as speaker. The residents of New York’s 8th congressional district were choosing a U.S. House representative, and the district is so overwhelmingly Democratic that the race was all but uncontested.
Hakeem Jeffries’ first congressional race was in 2012 when he ran for the Democratic nomination against New York City Councilman Charles Barron, a former Black Panther and self-proclaimed socialist. Not surprisingly, Jeffries had full establishment support in the primary, including former Mayor Ed Koch, Brooklyn Democratic Party boss Vito Lopez, labor unions, and Sen. Chuck Schumer. (President Barack Obama’s endorsement was implied.) Even out-of-state Democratic donors flooded the race with cash to block Barron. Jeffries beat Barron 72 to 28 percent. He boasted, “The political pundits said that this was going to be a close race, but that was before the people had spoken.” Sure, technically, the Democratic establishment and deep-pocketed donors are people. It’s not as much of a stretch as Mitt Romney’s claim that year that “corporation are people,” but it’s still an eye-rolling assertion.
Jeffries’s supporters — particularly the smug “don’t you know how Congress works?” types online — point out that his election as speaker is inevitable and all this talk about anyone else replacing him is unserious. After all, it’s not as if there are other candidates, but that’s not exactly exonerating. There will be an election where Congress members vote for speaker, but if the outcome is predetermined (all Republicans voting for “legislative terrorist” Jim Jordan because they’ve learned nothing, and all Democrats voting for Jeffries), that’s not a true election. It’s as sham process, one more tedious and ego-inflating than all the standing and applause before the encore at a concert.
Nancy Pelosi stepped down as Democratic leader in 2022, and Jeffries was her Prince Charles — well, actually, her original heir apparent was Joe Crowley, who Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez retired in 2018. (Jeffries owes AOC a bouquet of flowers and a box of chocolates.) I’m hardly enthusiastic about Jeffries’ performance as minority leader, but House Democrats did actually gain a couple seats in 2024 when Trump won again. Whereas Schumer lost the Senate outright. Jeffries did lead the Democrats’ united response when a desperate Trump started a redistricting war to keep the House under GOP control. Jeffries comes off like a PowerPoint deck in a human suit, but he still communicates more effectively than Schumer. This probably explains why even Chris Van Hollen, who’s challenging Schumer for Senate leader, has endorsed Jeffries. Specifically, Van Hollen said, “He’s never served as speaker. He’s been the minority leader.” This is true, unlike Schumer who was previously majority leader under President Joe Biden from 2021 through 2024. He had a Democratic House for two of those years and had the chance to pass significant legislation. Like Tom Buchanan’s post college life, everything afterward savors of anticlimax.
Schumer takes a lot of credit for Democrats who win Senate elections and very little blame for those who lose. (That’s very Trump-like.) Democrats lost two Senate seats overall in 2018, a blue wave election. That was admittedly a tough Senate map, but they erect statues for the leaders who prevail during challenging circumstances. Democrats gained five seats in 2020 and 2021 for a bare-minimum 50-seat majority. This was less than polls had predicted. During the primaries, Schumer had backed Cal Cunnigham in North Carolina and Sara Gideon in Maine, both of whom lost. (Cunningham face planted over the dullest sexting scandal possible.) I also think Pelosi played a more decisive role in forcing Biden to abandon his doomed re-election campaign, which likely saved Senate seats in Arizona, Nevada, Michigan, and Wisconsin. Although Schumer gently urged Biden to drop out in a private meeting and later wept in his car, Pelosi went full gangster and threatened to release internal polling that showed Biden stinking up the joint.
Democrats flipped nine Senate seats this year and held their seats in swing states Trump had carried in 2024. Yes, Schumer raised a lot of money to this end, but he’s acting as if he came up with the innovative strategy of “recruiting” candidates like Sherrod Brown, Roy Cooper, and Mary Peltola. Brown might have needed some nudging because he’s 74 and wouldn’t mind retiring, but I doubt that Cooper and Peltola required much arm-twisting to run in a Democratic-friendly environment. Both Democrats launched their campaigns when Trump’s approval had cratered.
Schumer is very good with “well, duh” choices for Senate, sort of like a Hollywood executive approving a major Tom Cruise film, but he’s also made some choices that blew up in his face, like a Hollywood executive approving a major Tom Cruise film. He backed Janet Mills in Maine, an unpopular sitting governor, and most curiously of all, Haley Stevens in Michigan. Schumer didn’t have to foresee her eventual heel turn. He should have just seen the existing video of her speaking out loud. (Watch below.)
Schumer has a documented history, though, of claiming credit for positive outcomes that occur within his vicinity. A recent New York Magazine article describes how a 27-year-old Schumer, then a state assemblyman), got a story placed in the New York Times about how he apprehended someone who’d allegedly broken into a constituent’s home.
Burglars were apparently rampant in his neighborhood “like a pack of wolves on the prowl,” Schumer told the Times, as if we were composing an entry in Travis Bickle’s journal. “The house was a complete shambles. It looked like the first battle of Bull Run had gone inside.”
“While I’m on the phone with the police,” he said, “I hear them coming down the stairs and I give chase. There are two of them, a boy 16, and a girl, 14. The boy is all the way down the block already. I couldn’t catch up with him, but the girl is slower.”
As the girl ran; and Mr. Schumer ran after, a mailman, George Kenniff, happened by while on his daily rounds. “I yelled, ‘Help me. Stop her!”’ Mr. Schumer recalled; “and he put his cart in the way and I caught up to her and held her. She was screaming and kicking for five minutes.”
Seems like it was the mailman who actually caught this teenage public enemy number one. Well, at least Schumer didn’t go Fetterman on the child and hold her at gunpoint.
Even if Schumer were primarily responsible for Democratic victories this year (and he’s not), he should still make the case for serving as leader for another congressional session. Besides, he’s been in leadership for more than a decade. Presidents only serve two terms for a reason.
Yet Democratic Senators who support Van Hollen for leader have to justify their support for an actual democratic process.
“It’s not that I oppose Schumer just to oppose Schumer,” Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed told The Majority Report. “He was very supportive of me in the general. But this is about how we are able to earn the mandate that makes this outcome the floor, not the ceiling, right? The idea that we have 56 senators, that’s amazing. But how many more could we get if we demonstrate that we're actually solving the problems that people need? And I think that’s new leadership.” (Watch below.)
Schumer is 76, and his supporters argue we should gift him the leadership position like a gold watch before his likely retirement in 2028. But if you’ve learned anything from Joe Biden, Dianne Fienstein, and the remains of Mitch McConnell and Chuck Grassley, you would not assume that a retirement is all that likely. Leaders rarely surrender power willingly, and Schumer might find it hard to resist leading a sizable Senate majority under a Democratic president.
Congressional leadership shouldn’t be a sinecure. There should be contested elections with a vigorous debate. That’s democracy. It’s worth a try.








Jeffries is better than Schumer, because during the last budget showdown he held his team together while Schumer (who made clear he wasn’t a fan of the showdown at all) wound up caving for nothing. Jeffries I get the sense tries to reflect his caucus, for better or worse. He’s also younger, which should mean something. And Republicans simply can’t as easily use him in their ads to scare away voters (yes, he’s black, but good luck trying to make that guy look scary—just picture that unintentionally hilarious photo of him holding the baseball bat).
Schumer though is completely washed up. Not just his age, but his way of thinking is calcified in the last century. He’s another Boomer who wants to hold onto power at the expense of everything he claimed to fight for (remember RBG? Amy Coney Barret sure does!). He exudes weakness, has zero leverage with disloyal bags of shit like Fetterman or Sinema, no leverage with red state unicorns like Manchin, his spirit animals are weak reeds like Kaine and Durbin. Nearly blowing it with his Michigan and Maine picks demonstrate his total misread of candidates. He has no strategic acumen, consistently voting for Trump nominees as though the Fairy of Civility is going to give him a cookie. And his very personal exudes “old Wall Street New Yorker who is selling your debt to a collection agency.” Republicans are happy to feature him in their ads.
I'm not a fan of either man, really, but I am more inclined to give Jeffries a pass than Schumer. Jeffries is presiding over a large group of ideologically diverse lawmakers, some from bright blue socialist friendly districts, others from ones Trump won by 20 points. He simply *has* to be more ideologically flexible than the online mobs want him to be if he wants to hold his caucus together. Hopefully in short time he can be dragged to the left on some current Dem priorities.
Schumer is another story. He's given us a ton of evidence his political radar is stuck in 1992, and he seems simply out of step with the views of the modern Democratic party. It's worth a look at the ones who are backing him (including my own state's most prominent fossil, Angus King) vs the ones backing Van Hollen, who is no spring chicken himself (67) but seems more inclined to take advantage of what could be an enormous step forward for the Democratic party.
I also don't think two leaders from one state is a really good idea, but that is a secondary concern. So I'll be watching this with interest.